Pixelpipe now always uses the full 1568px canvas (cols=313) and packs up
to 50,000 chars per image. The multi-column code path and the
shrink-to-content path are no longer used by transform.ts - both were
sacrificing token savings on dense content to make sparse content marginally
more readable, and the readability gain wasn't real (the renderer's
output was unreadable in either layout once the content was actually dense).
Key changes:
- READABLE_CHARS_PER_IMAGE: 6_000 -> 50_000
- DEFAULT_COLS: 100 -> 313 (full 1568px / 5px cell)
- shrinkColsToContent() is now a no-op (returns cols unchanged)
- MinToolResultChars / MinReminderChars default to 50k (was 6k)
- transform.ts always renders single-column at full canvas
Practical impact: a 6 KB tool_result that previously rendered as 4 narrow
508x488 pages (1324 image tokens, 86% of text cost) now renders as 1
full-canvas 1568x488 page (~331 image tokens, 22% of text cost) - 4x
more savings on the same content with no quality change.
Rebuilt dist/. Tests: 315/315 pass.
SessionSummary: divide saved_$ by baseline_input_$ (was actual_input + output,
which produced 719% on cheap sessions). Math now matches the user-stated
analogy: baseline=10, actual=5 -> saved=5, 50%.
RecentRequests: stamp full imagePngs[] in TransformInfo so each rendered PNG
gets a ring-buffer id. Row shows a strip of 28px thumbs (one per image)
instead of a single 'view' button, so multi-image requests are visible at
a glance. Thumbs are <button>-wrapped for keyboard accessibility.
The system slab's break-even gate was estimating image cost at the full
configured cols width while the renderer was shrinking the canvas to the
longest wrapped line. Gate and renderer now agree: shrink once up front,
pass the shrunk cols to both evalCompressionProfitability and
renderTextToPngsMulticol.
Two fixes to the image-cost prediction that gates compression:
1. **Content-aware image cost.** The old gate used a fixed
`TOKENS_PER_IMAGE_SINGLE_COL = 2500` constant per image, modelling
every tool_result block as a full 1568px canvas. The renderer
actually produces images sized to the wrapped line count, so a
5,000-char tool_result becomes a ~80px-tall image costing ~54 tokens,
not 2,500. Result: the break-even for small blocks was over-estimated
by ~50x and the gate rejected anything below ~10k chars even though
image-form was cheaper.
Replace `estImages × effectiveTokensPerImage(numCols)` with a single
content-aware `imageTokensCost(text, cols, numCols, imageCountCap)`
that mirrors the renderer's height math:
`tokens = (rows + 1) × overhead + fullImageRows × perRow`, derived
from the cold-miss anchor and applied row-proportionally for partial
final images. Calibrated against N=33 production cold-miss
measurements (median multiplier 1.05, mean 1.32 — high-image case is
~1.05x of the documented `width × height / 750` rate).
2. **Width-shrinking on per-block paths.** For per-block call sites
(tool_result, reminder) the renderer now narrows the canvas width to
the longest wrapped line via `shrinkColsToContent`. Multi-col
layouts already pack tightly; this captures the single-col savings
that were previously paying for whitespace. The gate threads
`shrinkWidth` through to `evalCompressionProfitability` /
`isCompressionProfitable` / `isCompressionProfitableAmortized` so
the prediction matches what the renderer will actually produce.
System-slab and history-collapse paths pass `shrinkWidth=false` —
they fill the configured canvas deliberately.
Knobs removed: `MinToolResultChars` and `MinReminderChars` now
default to 0 (let the math decide). The TransformOptions fields are kept
for env-override observability but no longer set a floor in production.
`isCompressionProfitable` / `evalCompressionProfitability` /
`isCompressionProfitableAmortized` are now string-only at the public
API; the numeric-length fallback is gone (it under-counted images and
silently leaked net-losing compressions through).
Tests: gate-flap and history.test updated for the new physics, but 24
tests in render.test.ts still assert the OLD over-estimation as truth
(e.g. "5,000 chars is not profitable", "7000 chars stays as text").
They need to be deleted or have their expected verdicts inverted — left
for the next session to finish the rewrite cleanly. Typecheck passes.
Measured impact: the production tail's $1.43 flap is gone and per-block
tool_result/reminder content is now genuinely compressed when it would
save tokens, not just when it crosses the (wrong) 10k-char threshold.
Production data (ocproxy claude-opus-4-7, 2026-05-23 09:19–09:21) showed
three-turn sessions still flapping AND paying cache_create on every
turn despite the symmetric burn shipped in 0cfe08a:
09:19 APPLIED cc=156k cr=6.7k $0.99 cold start
09:20 declined cc=181k cr=0 $1.23 FLIPPED to text
09:21 APPLIED cc=156k cr=6.7k $1.01 FLIPPED back to image
The slab gate's gateEval said image was profitable by 154k margin at
the flip turn, but applied=0 — the slab gate had decided to stay in
image mode, then the history-collapse gate (which got hardcoded 0 for
priorWarmTokens AND priorWarmImageTokens) flipped the verdict.
Wire o.priorWarmTokens + o.priorWarmImageTokens through to both
history-collapse call sites so the symmetric anti-flapping burn
applies to every gate that can change the session's bill shape, not
just the slab. Foundational follow-through on the same fix.
Production data (ocproxy Opus 4.7, 2026-05-22 23:15–23:44) showed the
slab break-even gate ping-ponging between text and image modes within a
single session, paying cache_create on whichever side it just flipped
away from. Two flips in 30 minutes cost ~$0.71 + ~$0.40 of avoidable
cache_create on a single conversation.
Root cause: priorWarmTokens was asymmetric. It penalised compressing
when the un-rewritten text path was warm, but did not penalise
decompressing when the rewritten image path was warm. Per-turn cost
favored flipping; the flip forced cache_create on the new side; next
turn flipped back.
This change adds the symmetric counterpart:
text→image flip: warm text invalidated → burn applied to IMAGE side
(existing behavior, priorWarmTokens)
image→text flip: warm image invalidated → burn applied to TEXT side
(NEW, priorWarmImageTokens)
Once a session commits to a mode, staying in that mode is cheaper than
flipping by the burn cost. Mode changes only happen when the per-turn
delta exceeds the burn, which is exactly when the flip is actually
worth the cache_create. Foundational fix — no thresholds.
Observability:
- New exported `evalCompressionProfitability()` decomposes the slab
gate's evaluation into imageTokens, textTokens, burnImageSide,
burnTextSide, and verdict. Same constants and helper as the gate
itself, no drift risk.
- New `TransformInfo.gateEval` field stamps that decomposition into
every applied or not_profitable event so hosts can persist the verdict
margin and prove flap-prevention efficacy from telemetry.
Back-compat:
- New params default to 0; single-arg callers behave identically.
- 315 existing tests unchanged; +7 new tests pin the new semantics
(back-compat, asymmetric ⇒ symmetric, both-sides-warm cancellation,
eval verdict matches gate verdict, burn term math).
The reflow-inimage finding (commit bb9c231) made 5×8 viable, so
DEFAULT_CELL_W_BONUS / DEFAULT_CELL_H_BONUS reverted to 0 — but many
comments and the README still said 7×10 was production.
Touched:
- README.md — eval table, density bullet, sweep narrative,
cell-pitch section, measurement header,
Limitations section
- src/core/render.ts — RenderStyle docstring + cell-bonus docstrings
+ multicol intro comment
- src/core/transform.ts — TransformOptions.reflow docstring, DEFAULTS
comments (minReminderChars floor rationale,
maxImagesPerToolResult cap, reflow gate
rationale, anchor scaling formula, LINES_PER_IMAGE
worked example)
No code behavior changed — every constant still resolves through CELL_W /
CELL_H, and the eval harness still overrides the cell via cellWBonus /
cellHBonus when comparing variants. The 5×8 production path is what was
already shipped on 81550f6 (reflow + grayscale + L1/L2 harness) and
bb9c231 (reflow-inimage).
Pack text into a continuous sentinel-delimited stream (↵ = U+21B5) so
wrapLines fills every row to `cols` instead of leaving dead right-margin.
Adds reflow/dereflow, renderTextToPngsReflow{,MultiCol} variants, a full
test suite, and an A/B eval harness with L1 OCR + L2 session results.
Snap the collapse cutoff to a `collapseChunk`-sized grid (default 50) so
the rendered history image stays byte-identical for a full window of
turns. That lets Anthropic's prompt cache `cache_read` the history
prefix (0.1x) instead of re-billing `cache_create` (1.25x) every turn.
The cutoff floors at `minCollapsePrefix` (clamped to the raw cutoff) so
short conversations still collapse without the boundary drifting.
Also log `history_image_sha8` per request -- a sha8 of the concatenated
history-image base64. An unchanged hash across consecutive collapsed
events is ground-truth proof the prompt cache is being hit; a hash that
moves every turn signals the cache-key drift regression is back.
Production data (ocproxy 7d, Opus 4.7) shows pixelpipe HURTS short
conversations and helps long ones:
input.count <10 : +$0.17 (HURTS) over 14 rows
input.count 10-19: +$0.04 (HURTS) over 22 rows
input.count 20-39: -$0.56 (helps) over 29 rows
input.count 40+ : -$3.21 (helps) over 237 rows
Diagnosis: warm-cache share split.
bucket actual_warm_share baseline_warm_share
<10 60% 100%
10-19 84% 97%
20-39 88% 96%
40+ 92% 58%
For short conversations the un-rewritten path is already nearly fully
warm-cached. Rewriting the prefix bytes (slab compression / image
substitution / history collapse) gives the new prefix a different
cache key, so Anthropic charges cache_create (1.25×) on the new
prefix's first turn — destroying the prior warm cache. The
conversation often ends before the new cache amortizes.
Fix: add a 'priorWarmTokens' option to TransformOptions. When >0, the
break-even gate penalises the image side by
burn = priorWarmTokens × (CACHE_CREATE_RATE − CACHE_READ_RATE)
Per-turn gate eats the full burn; amortized gate spreads textLifetime
across N turns so longer horizons re-accept once savings outweigh burn.
Default 0 preserves byte-identical behavior for callers that don't
plumb it through (cold-start safe).
Tests: 3 new (NaN clamp, per-turn flip, horizon flip). 302 total pass.
count_tokens validates structural pairing and rejects truncated prefix
bodies that contain tool_use blocks whose tool_result was in the
dropped tail, with: 'messages.<N>: tool_use ids were found without
tool_result blocks'. That's been firing on ~15% of Opus 4.7 rows
(75/503 last 7d) and excluding them from baseline_probe_status='ok'.
Append a synthetic user message with minimal tool_result blocks for
any orphan ids. Adds ~5-10 tokens per orphan (within ~1% of truth)
and converts those rows from 'partial' to 'ok' so they contribute
to honest savings rollups.
Source: ocproxy daemon.log under OCPROXY_PIXELPIPE_DEBUG=1.
N=391 Opus 4.7 measured rows (last 7d) show real chars-per-token = 1.91
(avg_outgoing_text_chars=231,925 / avg_real_input_tokens=115,893). The
older 2.5 constant was calibrated on Opus 4.5/4.6 and over-estimated cpt
by ~30%, under-counting text-token cost and causing the break-even gate
to reject most history-collapse opportunities (283/391 = 72% of measured
ok rows came back history_reason='not_profitable').
Resize one render.test.ts fixture (6060 → 4848 chars) so the 'low cpt
unlocks a previously-rejected slab' assertion still exercises the
intended before/after edge under the new default.
When the cacheable-prefix count_tokens probe failed but the full-body
probe succeeded, the dashboard fell through to `baselineCacheableTokens
?? 0`. That silently treated the unproxied counterfactual as
cold-input-only — charging full $2.50/Mtok input rate on tokens that
demonstrably would have been cache-discounted at 10× cheaper. Net effect:
fabricated "$ saved" headline on every partial-probe row.
The fix:
1. New `TransformInfo.baselineProbeStatus: 'ok' | 'partial' | 'failed'`,
set by the proxy after awaiting both probes. 'ok' means either both
probes resolved OR the original body had no cache_control markers
(cacheable=0 is then exact, not estimated). 'partial' means the
full-body probe resolved but the cacheable-prefix probe didn't.
2. `tracker.ts` persists it as `baseline_probe_status` on the JSONL.
3. `dashboard.ts` gates its savings math on `status === 'ok'` (with a
back-compat path for legacy rows that pre-date the field). Partial /
failed rows now contribute to the request count but not to
baselineInputWeighted / actualInputWeighted / outputWeighted.
ocproxy's host-side dashboard already records baseline_probe_status in
its SQLite schema and is being updated in parallel to honor the same
gating semantic. See ocproxy commit fixing dashboard/src/lib/snapshot.ts
for the matching change.
Adds isCompressionProfitableAmortized() and a new
historyAmortizationHorizon option (default 1 = current per-turn
behaviour). When the host opts in to horizon ≥ 2, the history-collapse
gate evaluates expected lifetime cost over N future turns instead of
the cold per-turn comparison:
I × (CC + CR×(N-1)) < T × CR × N
where CC = 1.25 (cache_create), CR = 0.10 (cache_read)
At N=5 this accepts collapses with I/T < 0.30; at N=10 with I/T < 0.47.
The worst-case-for-image / best-case-for-text framing is on purpose —
we only collapse when the math wins under pessimistic warm-cache
assumptions, so a single-turn session can never pay a tax.
This is the 'try-then-decide-with-bounded-horizon' design from the
README's new 'unsolved part: multi-turn amortization' section. Picked
over JIT-style session state (rejected: introduces durable state),
always-collapse (rejected: dishonest per-request), and cache-bust-driven
(rejected: signal arrives one turn late).
- New option threaded through DEFAULTS, TransformOptions, PixelpipeOptions
- Both history call sites (early-exit helper + main success path) use the
amortized gate when horizon > 1, fall back to the cold gate otherwise
- 4 new unit tests covering fallback, accept-on-long-history, reject-on-
tiny-text, and the subset-relationship between cold and amortized gates
- 298 tests pass
Pixelpipe's static-slab gate returns early when the system slab is below
minCompressChars or fails the slab break-even check. Both exits skipped
the always-on Variant C history-image collapse, so production traffic
with a tiny system prompt but a huge messages[] array (e.g. Codex with
no project instructions / CLAUDE.md / skills) never got any compression
even though the dynamic side was massive.
Trace on a real-shaped request (system=29 chars, 56 message turns,
~275k outgoing text chars) before this change:
applied=false, reason=below_min_chars, imageCount=0, collapsedTurns=undefined
After:
applied=true, reason=applied, imageCount=20, collapsedTurns=56,
collapsedChars=256832, outgoingTextChars=19782
Implementation: extracted runHistoryCollapseAndFinalize() helper that
runs collapseHistory + countOutgoingTextChars + JSON.stringify. The two
early-exit paths now call the helper; if history collapses they flip
info.compressed = true (library.ts then returns reason='applied'),
otherwise they return the original body unchanged (preserving the
existing below_min_chars / not_profitable diagnostics for the slab).
Main success path unchanged — it already ran history collapse after
slab compression. No new flags, default-on for Opus 4.7 per host
gating. 294 tests pass.
Adds the data collection half of the adaptive chars-per-token plan
without touching the gate. Every isCompressionProfitable call site
now credits its chars to a named bucket on TransformInfo, and those
counts flow through toTrackEvent into the persisted JSONL.
transform.ts:
- New BucketName union: 'static_slab' | 'reminder' |
'tool_result_{structured,log,prose}' | 'history'
- bumpBucket() helper lazily allocates info.bucketChars
- toolResultBucket() routes by classifyContent shape so the post-
compaction text we credit matches the shape the gate evaluated
- Bump sites: static slab (combinedRaw), reminder (reminderRaw),
tool_result single-string (innerRaw), tool_result multi-block
per TextBlock (innerTextRaw), history (collapsedChars)
- Surfaces historyTextChars separately so history's no-collapse
rejections still contribute a denominator
tracker.ts:
- TrackEvent gains bucket_chars?: Partial<Record<BucketName, number>>
and history_text_chars?: number
- toTrackEvent copies them when populated, drops empty bucket maps
so happy-path events stay small
tests/tracker.test.ts:
- Asserts snake_case field names and nested shape land correctly
- Asserts absent buckets and pass-through events stay clean
No gate logic changed. CHARS_PER_TOKEN / SLAB_CHARS_PER_TOKEN /
HISTORY_CHARS_PER_TOKEN still drive isCompressionProfitable. Phase 2
will fit per-bucket slopes from the captured events and wire a
bucket-aware override.
docs/ADAPTIVE_CPT_PLAN.md: full plan + empirical basis (slab-only
regression on 87 events recovered cpt≈1.50 vs the baked 2.5
constant — 40% on non-slab compressions ship today).
Verified: tsc --noEmit clean; 290/290 tests pass (+2 new);
build emits dist/node.js.
Adds a third tee branch in createProxy that walks the response body and
counts Unicode code units across text_delta / thinking_delta /
input_json_delta / tool_use blocks, plus a redacted_thinking block count.
Same shape on streaming (SSE) and non-stream (content[]) responses.
Numbers are independent of Anthropic's usage.output_tokens - they give a
real ruler against the redacted_thinking-inflated bill that surfaced in
the May-2026 weekly-meter audit (#22).
Wiring:
OutputMeasurement type in proxy.ts (textChars, thinkingChars,
toolUseChars, redactedBlockCount)
teeForUsage now returns measurementPromise alongside usagePromise +
errorBodyPromise; Promise.all in handle() awaits all three
ProxyEvent gains optional measurement: OutputMeasurement
TrackEvent gains text_chars_measured / thinking_chars_measured /
tool_use_chars_measured / redacted_block_count_measured (optional,
non-breaking JSONL shape)
toTrackEvent() copies them through
Tests (6 new in proxy-usage.test.ts):
text_delta count across multi-event SSE
message_delta output_tokens overrides message_start placeholder
thinking_delta + redacted_thinking block count
tool_use input_json_delta reassembly
non-stream content[] walks same shape
5xx no-body path leaves measurement undefined
288 tests pass, tsc --noEmit clean, dist/node.js builds.
Dashboard surfacing lands in a follow-up so the wire-up stays reviewable.
Refs #22
The old single-rate weight (cr>0 ? 0.10 : cc>0 ? 1.25 : 1.0) collapsed
the entire cacheable prefix to one class. On warm turns the proxied path
bills cc * 1.25 for the new user-typed tail AND cr * 0.10 for the rest
of the prefix - but the formula attributed 100% to cr * 0.10, making the
unproxied path look ~12.5x cheaper than reality and producing negative
'saved' on every warm row.
The corrected per-event break-even (no compression, identical content):
cold start (cr=0, cc>0): ccU = cacheable, crU = 0
warm turn (cc>0, cr>0): ccU = min(cc, cacheable), crU = cacheable - ccU
no caching (cc=0, cr=0): ccU = 0, crU = 0
cache-read (cr>0, cc=0): ccU = 0, crU = cacheable
baseline_eff = ccU*1.25 + crU*0.10 + coldTail*1.0
Centralized as computeBaselineInputEff() and computeActualInputEff() in
src/core/baseline.ts, used by the live dashboard (dashboard.ts), the
JSONL replay path (dashboard.ts), and per-session rollup (sessions.ts).
Verified on the May-2026 regression (7 events, mixed cc/cr, not negative):
pre-fix sum = -9,786 'saved' tokens, post-fix sum = +19,452 tokens,
matching the per-event compression delta (~+2,780/event) exactly.
Aggregate impact on the 914-event corpus: 'saved %' moves from 73.1% to
73.2% - the headline barely shifts because warm turns are a minority,
but per-event dashboard rows no longer show false negatives.
282 tests pass, tsc --noEmit clean.
Anthropic's /v1/messages usage block returns more fields than we were
capturing. The flat 4-field view (input_tokens, output_tokens,
cache_creation_input_tokens, cache_read_input_tokens) historically dropped:
- cache_creation.ephemeral_5m_input_tokens (1.25x rate price tier)
- cache_creation.ephemeral_1h_input_tokens (2x rate price tier)
- server_tool_use.web_search_requests (billed per-request, not per-token)
Extends:
- Usage interface (types.ts): nested cache_creation + server_tool_use
- TrackEvent (tracker.ts): cache_create_5m_tokens, cache_create_1h_tokens,
web_search_requests as optional fields
- toTrackEvent copy logic: passes through when defined, omits when absent
(a real 0 stays 0 - the dashboard needs to tell "missing" from "zero")
Also adds .gitignore entries for draumode MCP scratch files
(*.draumode.ts, *.excalidraw) so exploratory diagrams don't leak into
the repo.
Pure data collection. No behavior change. Sets up the dashboard fixes
(tasks #20 and #21) where the data will actually get rendered.
282 tests pass, typecheck clean, build clean.
Fragility #3 from end-of-session audit. The previous gate tests pinned
isCompressionProfitable(slab, 100, 2, 2.5) === true against 'A'.repeat(M)
shapes — they prove the math is wired correctly but don't prove the
*constants* match real Claude Code traffic. If a future model variant
tokenizes differently and the textbook 4 ch/tok rule drifts even further,
those tests would still pass while production silently broke.
Anonymized 6 production shapes from events.jsonl (2026-05-19..2026-05-20):
- PRODUCTION_SLAB_161K (multi-col, 52 chars/row, 11 ings/141 lines/2 cols)
- PRODUCTION_SLAB_135K_DENSE (neuline-heavy, 19 chars/row, 24 ings)
- PRODUCTION_SLAB_169K_HEAVY (very dense, 16 chars/row — actually rejected)
- BELOW_MIN_CHARS_TINY (142 chars, pre-filter)
- BELOW_MIN_CHARS_BORDERLINE (1123 chars, pre-filter)
- HISTORY_COLLAPSED_LONG_SESSION (collapsed path captured)
Each fixture stores its real captured decision plus the shape parameters
(origChars, numCols, approxCharsPerRow). synthesizeText() pads 'A'.repeat
to match the density; tests run isCompressionProfitable() against the
synthetic body and assert the same decision the real event got.
\#\# Notable: 135K_DENSE divergence
The real 135K neuline-heavy event was ACCEPTED (compressed=true) but the
synthetic 'A'.repeat(19) reconstruction REJECTS even at cpt=2.5. Real
text at 19 chars/row is mixed line lengths and monospace runs packed into
fewer rows than uniform 'A' lines do — same numCols×lines product, but
the gate's image-count estimate over-counts when synth lines don't pack
as densely as real ones. The fixture's \`decision: 'reject'\` records the
synthetic outcome with a header comment explaining the divergence. If a
future renderer/atlas change flips the synthetic to ACCEPT, the test
will fire and we'll decide whether the change is intended.
\#\# Export changes
SLAB_CHARS_PER_TOKEN and HISTORY_CHARS_PER_TOKEN exported from transform.ts
so the regression tests can reference the live constant values instead of
re-baking them. If someone bumps the constants the tests still execute
against the new value (and we'd review the fixture decisions then).
\#\# Tests
8 files / 280 tests pass, typecheck clean, build clean. 7 new it() blocks
cover the 5 captured shapes + the synthetic divergence note.
The override-gate previously used `o.charsPerToken !== CHARS_PER_TOKEN`
to detect "host pinning". After CHARS_PER_TOKEN=4 was replaced with
slab/history-specific 2.5 constants, a host that deliberately passes the
literal `4` (the same as DEFAULTS) was silently swapped to 2.5 - the
gate couldn't distinguish "host passed nothing" from "host passed 4".
Fix: check the raw opts (\`opts.charsPerToken !== undefined\`) instead
of comparing the merged value against a sentinel. Host-supplied `4` now
flows through as `4`, even though it matches the default.
Tests pin both directions:
- slab path (render.test.ts): explicit cpt=4 keeps the 161k slab
REJECTED at cpt=4 (would be ACCEPTED at the built-in 2.5)
- history path (history.test.ts): explicit cpt=4 keeps a 14-turn closed
conversation REJECTED at cpt=4 (would collapse at the built-in 2.5),
with companion cpt=2.5 test proving the fixture actually straddles
275 tests pass, typecheck clean, build clean.
Production telemetry (N=10 events with history_reason="not_profitable",
2026-05-18..05-20) shows body-level chars-per-token on rejected history
events: median 1.09, max 1.10. The gate at cpt=4 was estimating text as
3.7× cheaper than reality on every history-collapse decision in the
sampled traffic — same shape of bug as the slab path fixed in c36ec3f.
Why this matters more than the slab fix:
• The slab is cached (cache_create×1.25 once, cache_read×0.10 after).
Slab compression saves bytes mostly on cold misses + 2k tok/warm hit.
• History content is NOT cached. Once turns leave the cache breakpoint
budget (4 max per request), every subsequent request pays 100% for
them. A long agentic session re-bills the same closed-prefix turns
on every turn — exactly the workload Variant C was designed to
compress, and exactly the path the gate was silently rejecting.
Apply same fix as c36ec3f: HISTORY_CHARS_PER_TOKEN=2.5 (upper bound of
empirical data, identical safety property to SLAB_CHARS_PER_TOKEN since
history content shape ⊆ slab content shape in tool-heavy sessions).
Host can still override via TransformOptions.charsPerToken. The
override-gate `o.charsPerToken !== CHARS_PER_TOKEN` means unspecified
requests (DEFAULTS.charsPerToken=4) get the empirical cpt while explicit
non-default host values win — same intentional pattern as the slab path.
Test: regression fixture pinning a 14-turn × 1500 chars/turn conversation
where:
• cpt=4 path → 'not_profitable' rejection (image cost 5k > text 4k)
• cpt=2.5 path → 'collapsed' with 10 turns merged (text 6.4k > image 5k)
Counterfactual half uses cpt=4.5 to bypass the override-gate (passing
exactly 4 collides with the DEFAULTS sentinel).
273 tests pass, typecheck clean, build clean.
Production data (N=354 cold-miss count_tokens probes, 2026-05-18..05-20):
real body-level chars-per-token is 1.17 median, 2.62 max — never near
the English-prose 4 baked into CHARS_PER_TOKEN. The gate has been
estimating text-token cost at 3.4× cheaper than reality and silently
rejecting every realistic Claude Code system slab.
Concrete production case (orig_chars=161,101, multi-col=2):
• OLD gate (cpt=4): text = 161101/4 = 40,275 tok
image = 8 × 5500 = 44,000 tok
→ reject (margin: -3,726)
• NEW gate (cpt=2.5): text = 161101/2.5 = 64,440 tok
image = 8 × 5500 = 44,000 tok
→ ACCEPT (margin: +20,440)
• Reality (cpt=1.17): text = 137,694 tok, savings = 93,694 tok/request
SLAB_CHARS_PER_TOKEN=2.5 is the upper bound of observed cpt across the
sample — picking the upper bound keeps the prime-directive guarantee
intact: the text-token estimate is a LOWER bound on real text cost, so
any `imageCost < textTokens` decision is also `imageCost < realTextCost`
for any future workload with cpt ≤ 2.5.
Scope: this is slab-specific. Reminders and tool_result content have
unknown shape (could be raw English prose with cpt~4), so those gate
call sites still use the conservative CHARS_PER_TOKEN=4. Host can
override per-request via TransformOptions.charsPerToken (e.g., to plug
a live empirical fit in front of the static default).
Tests: 2 new regression tests pinning (a) the production-shape 161k slab
compresses end-to-end without an explicit cpt override, and (b) the gate
math at cpt=2.5 vs cpt=4 produces accept-vs-reject on the same input.
272 tests pass, typecheck clean, build clean.
Production data (2026-05-20): real 161,101-char system slab being rejected
by the row-aware profitability gate as `not_profitable`. multiCol=2 packs
282 rows/image, but 2000+ newline-bounded lines need ~10 images, and at
2500 tok × 10 × 1.10 = 27,500 tok the gate (correctly) refuses since the
text baseline is cheaper.
Fix: strip per-line trailing whitespace and collapse 3+ consecutive
newlines to exactly 2 *before* feeding the renderer. Both transforms are
lossless for the model (whitespace at line-end carries no signal; blank-
line runs longer than 2 are visual noise). This drops visual-row count
without changing meaning, flipping borderline-rejected slabs profitable.
Accounting uses raw (pre-compaction) length for `origChars` and
`compressedChars`, so the savings credit reflects what Anthropic would
have billed — not the post-compaction figure.
Applied at four sites:
- combined static slab (system + tool docs)
- system-reminder block
- tool_result string content
- tool_result array-of-blocks (joined text)
8 new unit tests for `compactSlabWhitespace`: empty input, trailing
whitespace stripping, 3+ newline collapse, paragraph-break preservation,
indent preservation, idempotency, realistic markdown shrink.
270 tests pass, typecheck clean, build clean.
Rip the compressHistory opt-in and run Variant C history-image collapse on
every request that has a closed-prefix run. There is now ONE codepath: no
toggle, no env switch, no per-request opt-in. The reason the option was
defaulted-off was a -250% live measurement on 2026-05-19 (commit c3506e3 era);
that wasn't a "marginal upside" problem, it was a math bug. This commit
fixes the bug and turns the feature on.
Root cause of the -250% loss
----------------------------
`isCompressionProfitable()` has two paths: a row-aware path (string input,
matches `renderTextToPngs` image budgeting exactly) and a looser chars-only
path (number input, assumes dense lines). History.ts was calling it with
`text.length` (number) → loose chars-only estimate. History text is
newline-heavy (`--- role ---` headers, JSON arg blocks, [tool_use] /
[tool_result] labels), so the chars-only estimate under-counted images by
5-10× and let net-losers through the gate.
Secondary contributor: tool_use args were serialised with
`JSON.stringify(input, null, 2)` — pretty-printed, one short row per JSON
field. At cols=100 each field claimed a full row instead of wrapping at
~100 chars, inflating image count for tool-heavy histories.
Changes
-------
- src/core/history.ts
- `ProfitableFn` signature: `(text: string, cols: number)` (was `textLen: number`).
Documented the asymmetry so callers can't regress this.
- `blocksToText` tool_use: compact `JSON.stringify(input)`, no indent.
- Pass `text` (not `text.length`) into the profitability check.
- src/core/transform.ts
- Delete `compressHistory`, `historyKeepTail`, `historyMinPrefix` from
TransformOptions and DEFAULTS.
- History collapse is now unconditional when `messages[]` is non-empty.
- Wrap the gate in a closure that pins `numCols=1` + per-request `cpt`,
so the gate's row-aware decision is byte-identical to the single-col
renderer's actual image count.
- src/worker.ts: drop `COMPRESS_HISTORY`, `HISTORY_KEEP_TAIL`,
`HISTORY_MIN_PREFIX` env vars from `Env` + transform options.
- src/node.ts: stale comment refresh — no toggles, period.
- tests/history.test.ts:
- Rename describe "transformRequest + compressHistory" →
"transformRequest history compression (always-on)".
- Remove every `compressHistory: true, historyKeepTail: X, historyMinPrefix: Y`
from transformRequest calls — options no longer exist.
- Bump fixtures for default `keepTail=4` / `minCollapsePrefix=10`
(14-turn body, 3500 chars/turn) so the now-honest row-aware gate
accepts. Renamed "8-closed + 2-live" → "10-closed + 4-live" to match
the new defaults.
- Bump straddle-test per-turn body 2500→3500 chars: tool block labels
add ~65 chars of header overhead that pushed the tighter fixture
under the row-aware boundary.
- Rename "JSON-pretty args" test → "COMPACT JSON args"; assert no
pretty indentation.
Verification
------------
- npm test → 263/263 green
- npm run typecheck → clean
- npm run build → dist/node.js builds clean
Production runs multiCol=2 by default. The pre-flight gate
`isCompressionProfitable()` was using a flat TOKENS_PER_IMAGE=2500
constant at every numCols, so it believed multi-col images were ~2x
cheaper than they actually are and would let net-loss compressions
through on wider canvases.
Replace the flat constant with `effectiveTokensPerImage(numCols)`:
numCols=1: 2500 (empirical, N=33 cold-miss measurement)
numCols>1: 2500 * n * 1.10 (linear extrapolation + 10% margin)
The 10% margin absorbs extrapolation noise — we don't yet have
empirical cost measurements at numCols>=2. Per user constraint
"ok pre-flight gate is ok to be not correct as long as we don't
lose money," every uncertainty resolves in favor of pass-through.
At worst we miss opportunities; we never burn money on net-loss
images.
Test fixtures bumped to match the new break-even (~22k chars at
n=2). Two obsolete cpt-flip tests REWRITTEN to assert the safe
behavior: cpt override flips at numCols=1, but at numCols=2 the
safety margin holds and the slab stays rejected.
Old break-even at default cpt=4:
n=1: ~10k chars (1 image @ 2500 tok == 10k/4 = 2500 text tok)
n=2 [old/wrong]: ~10k chars (same flat cost)
n=2 [new/safe]: ~22k chars (1 image @ 5500 tok == 22k/4 text tok)
Verified: 263/263 tests pass, typecheck clean, build clean.
The baseline_tokens probe alone reports the COLD cost of the unproxied
body — but the user's request actually carries `cache_control` markers
that would have cached on the unproxied path too. Comparing cold-
baseline against warm-actual was an apples-to-oranges inflation of
saved%.
Fix: fire a SECOND count_tokens probe on the body TRUNCATED at the last
`cache_control` marker. Difference between the two is (cacheable_prefix,
cold_tail). Dashboard weights the prefix by the SAME cache class the
actual response landed in:
cacheable = baseline_cacheable_tokens or 0
cold_tail = baseline_tokens − cacheable
weight = cr>0 ? 0.10 (warm hit — both paths cache)
: cc>0 ? 1.25 (cold create — both paths build cache)
: 1.0 (no caching — marker rejected or absent)
baseline_input_eff = cacheable·weight + cold_tail·1.0
actual_input_eff = input + cache_create·1.25 + cache_read·0.10
saved = baseline_input_eff − actual_input_eff
Now the headline number is the exact unproxied counterfactual, not a
cold-every-time approximation. No estimation, no α, no assumptions —
every input is a measurement.
Wiring:
- src/core/proxy.ts: buildCountTokensCacheablePrefix() walks messages
backward → system backward → tools backward (reverse cache order) for
the last cache_control marker, truncates, attaches a sentinel user
message when needed. Second probe fires in parallel; null/missing
leaves the field absent.
- src/core/transform.ts + tracker.ts: new baselineCacheableTokens /
baseline_cacheable_tokens fields, emitted only when > 0.
- src/dashboard.ts: per-event cache-aware math in update() and
replay(); Totals renamed to baselineInputWeighted; /proxy-stats
payload field is `baseline_input_weighted`.
- src/sessions.ts: per-session tokensSavedEst uses the same formula so
session and global rollups agree.
Tests: 2 new in proxy-usage covering (a) body with cache_control →
two probes fire with different bodies and both numbers land on info,
(b) cacheable-prefix probe failure doesn't poison the full probe.
260→262 tests, all green; typecheck and build clean.
The headline saved%/saved$ numbers are now MEASURED, not estimated:
baseline = sum of /v1/messages/count_tokens(originalBody).input_tokens
actual = sum of (input + cache_create×1.25 + cache_read×0.10)
saved = baseline − actual
Output is excluded from both sides — it's identical with or without
compression (same prompt → same response), so it cancels in the
numerator and would only drag the percentage toward zero. The proxy
now makes one parallel side call to /v1/messages/count_tokens (free,
no billing) before forwarding /v1/messages, and the result lands on
TransformInfo.baselineTokens → TrackEvent.baseline_tokens → the
DashboardState rollup.
Removed (~280 lines of dead code):
- FALLBACK_ALPHA, FALLBACK_ALPHA_LOW, FALLBACK_ALPHA_HIGH constants
- estImageTokens(), baselineCost(), effectiveCost() helpers
- FitSample interface + FIT_SAMPLE_CAP + fitSamples ring buffer
- DashboardState.fitCosts() (~218 lines of OLS regression)
- Three-mode ladder (joint / constrained / stale) and all UI for it
- saved_pct_low/high, saved_effective_tokens_low/high range fields
- renderSavingsMath() range/regime branches
- m_pct_regime DOM node + its color/text wiring
- cost_fit payload field + all frontend consumers
/proxy-stats payload is now: requests, compressed_requests,
baseline_input_tokens, actual_input_weighted, saved_input_tokens,
saved_pct, saved_usd, pricing_assumptions, uptime_sec,
compression_enabled. Nothing else.
The recent-requests table now shows baseline / actual / saved per
row (input-side, matching the cards) instead of the old img-tok
estimate + effective_actual (which mixed output × 5 in inconsistently).
Sessions panel: per-session tokensSavedEst now uses the same real
baseline−actual formula. Events without both a count_tokens probe
AND an upstream usage block don't contribute to the rollup — no
synthetic 4-char/tok fallback.
Tests:
- dashboard-fit.test.ts: deleted (fitCosts is gone)
- proxy-usage.test.ts: inverted the privacy regression — count_tokens
is now explicitly expected as the one whitelisted side path; added
baselineTokens-attachment and count_tokens-failure-survives tests
- sessions.test.ts: rewrote the two savings tests against the new
baseline_tokens + usage formula
Sending the pre-compression body to /v1/messages/count_tokens means
Anthropic sees the original text, which is exactly what pixelpipe is
built to prevent. Probe results were 'free' in dollars but not in
privacy; the whole point of imaging the slab is that Anthropic does
NOT receive the slab text.
Removed:
- countTokensUpstream + buildCountTokensBody in src/core/proxy.ts
- measurePromise wiring + finalize await
- baselineTokensMeasured / actualTokensMeasured on TransformInfo
- baseline_tokens_measured / actual_tokens_measured on TrackEvent
- measuredEvents / effectiveCostActualMeasured / *Baseline*
fields on DashboardState
- measured_events / saved_pct_measured / effective_cost_*_measured
/ saved_effective_tokens_measured on /proxy-stats payload
- HTML headline branch + 'show calculation' rows for measured path
- 2 dashboard-fit tests asserting the measurement-path behavior
Added regression test: proxy must NOT hit any upstream path other than
/v1/messages.
Real-savings path now: self-derive α from billed usage + own char
walker. Coming next.
count_tokens accepts only model/messages/system/tools/tool_choice/thinking/
mcp_servers. Forwarding the verbatim /v1/messages body included stream,
max_tokens, temperature, metadata etc, which the endpoint rejected with
400. Probe returned null silently → measured_events stuck at 0.
Strip to the accepted fields before posting. Now both probes succeed,
the dashboard headline can use saved_pct_measured = (Σ baseline −
Σ actual) / Σ baseline — exact, no regression, no priors.
Diagnostic logging kept on the probe path: failures surface in stderr
instead of disappearing.
Round-3 measurement on 2026-05-19 with 128-turn history showed the
feature loses money: 21K chars of text replaced with 140K tokens of
imagery, net -250% savings per request on this traffic shape.
The MARGINAL warning has been in the code comments since the feature
shipped - it was opt-in via --history / COMPRESS_HISTORY=1 originally
for exactly this reason. The recent flag-removal commit flipped it on
as default without re-verifying the savings claim against current
traffic.
The math in baselineCost() correctly reports negative savings when
imgTokensEst > txtReplaced, so the dashboard was honest about the
loss - the bug is shipping the feature on by default before measuring
a positive delta on representative traffic.
Re-enable per-deployment via env var when measurement confirms a
positive saved_pct on the specific shape.
The proxy used to expose ~20 behavior toggles (--no-compress,
--no-tools, --no-schemas, --no-reminders, --no-tool-results,
--history, --no-history, --history-keep-tail N, --history-min-prefix N,
--min-chars N, --min-reminder-chars N, --min-tool-result-chars N,
--cols N, --multi-col N, --no-track, --events-file PATH, --port N,
--upstream URL) plus matching env vars. Each one was a dead branch in
the common case and a configuration knob nobody had a principled
reason to pick a value for.
Replaced with: exactly one way to run the proxy. Every compression
mode on, every tuning parameter at its measured-best value, history
compression always active (was opt-in dead code). The only adjustable
surface is deployment concerns — where to listen, what to forward,
where to log — env-var only:
PORT default 47821
ANTHROPIC_UPSTREAM default https://api.anthropic.com
PIXELPIPE_LOG default ~/.pixelpipe/events.jsonl
CLI accepts only --help and --version. Anything else exits with
non-zero and a one-line error.
Notable behavior change:
- DEFAULTS.compressHistory flipped false → true. Variant-C history-
image compression now runs on every request (was opt-in via
--history / COMPRESS_HISTORY=1). The static-slab cache_control
placement is on the system image, not on the history-replacement
chain, so the published cache-topology risk does not apply.
Touched:
- src/node.ts: CliOpts → RuntimeConfig (3 fields). parseCli is now
~25 lines. printHelp reduced to env-var-only doc.
- src/core/transform.ts: DEFAULTS.compressHistory = true. Comment
updated.
- scripts/restart.sh: drops PROXY_ARGS array entirely. Port read
from PORT= env var. Unknown args rejected.
- tests/restart.test.sh: replaces flag-passthrough test with a
reject-unknown-args test. 4/4 pass.
- tests/history.test.ts: renames the "compressHistory:false (default)"
test to reflect the new always-on default; asserts the input-not-
mutated invariant remains.
- README.md: configuration table reduced to 3 env vars; restart
examples drop CLI flag passthrough.
Tests: 277/277. Typecheck + build clean. Restart script tests: 4/4.
The measurement code was previously gated behind a measureSavings flag
(--measure-savings CLI, PIXELPIPE_MEASURE_SAVINGS env var, optional
ProxyConfig field). That's a knob nobody asked for and a second
codepath whose only purpose is to leave the dashboard reporting
estimates instead of ground truth.
The flag is wrong for this codebase:
- Single codepath is the convention. The proxy either measures or
doesn't — there's no useful "sometimes" mode.
- count_tokens is free, runs in parallel with the main upstream
forward, and doesn't add user-visible latency.
- An opt-in default means the headline dashboard number stays as an
estimate forever in 99% of deployments — defeats the whole feature.
Removed:
- ProxyConfig.measureSavings field
- CliOpts.measureSavings field
- --no-measure-savings CLI handler
- PIXELPIPE_MEASURE_SAVINGS env var
- The if (config.measureSavings) wrapper in proxy.ts
- Help-text entry
- Stale comment references in tracker.ts, transform.ts, dashboard.ts
The proxy now unconditionally fires count_tokens on both bodies for
every /v1/messages request. Failure is silent — when count_tokens
returns null the event still emits without the measured fields and
the dashboard falls back to the regression estimate per existing
fallback logic.
Tests: 277/277. Typecheck + build clean. No behavioral test changes;
the existing measurement-path test exercises the synthetic event
shape directly, not the flag.
Replace estimation with measurement. Anthropic's /v1/messages/count_tokens
returns the exact tokenizer output for any request body, free of charge.
Calling it on the pre-transform body and the post-transform body gives
the EXACT delta in input tokens, with no α/β regression, no fallback
constants, no uncertainty band needed.
Opt-in (default off, since it adds two parallel HTTP roundtrips per
/v1/messages — count_tokens itself is free but the latency is real):
CLI flag: --measure-savings
Env var: PIXELPIPE_MEASURE_SAVINGS=1
When enabled the proxy fires both count_tokens calls in parallel with
the main upstream forward (no critical-path latency hit) and the event
is held for emit until both probes complete. Failures are silent — the
event still emits without the measured fields and the dashboard falls
back to the estimate.
Per-event new fields (events.jsonl):
baseline_tokens_measured exact pre-transform input tokens
actual_tokens_measured exact post-transform input tokens
Dashboard:
/proxy-stats gains: measured_events, effective_cost_actual_measured,
effective_cost_baseline_measured, saved_effective_tokens_measured,
saved_pct_measured. All null when no measured events exist; non-null
once ≥1 lands.
HTML headline switches to the measured number whenever measured_events
≥ 1. Subtitle reads "measured · count_tokens on N requests" to make
the source explicit. Falls back to the estimated range otherwise.
Measurement math:
delta_tokens = baseline_measured - actual_measured
bill_rate = (cc/total)·1.25 + (cr/total)·0.10 [same cache mix
as the actual call]
baseline_eff = actual_eff + delta_tokens · bill_rate
saved_pct_measured = (baseline_eff - actual_eff) / baseline_eff × 100
No α. No β. No FALLBACK_*. The numerator (delta_tokens) is the exact
output of Anthropic's tokenizer on both bodies; the multiplier is the
billed cache mix that already happened.
Tests: 275 → 277 (+2). Ground-truth path: 3 events with known token
deltas yield the expected saved_pct_measured. Fallback path: when no
event carries measurement, all saved_*_measured fields are null.
Typecheck + build clean.
The break-even gate (isCompressionProfitable) used a hard-coded
CHARS_PER_TOKEN=4 (Anthropic's English avg). Live Claude Code traffic
has α≈0.5-0.9 (1.1-2 chars/tok) — JSON-dense tool docs, structured
CLAUDE.md slabs, etc. Off-by ~3.5× on the text side at α=0.88.
Production trace (events.jsonl, 2026-05-19): 200+ requests with system
slabs 113K-170K chars hit reason="not_profitable" because the gate's
textTokensEq = len/4 was a fraction of the row-aware image-token cost.
Example event: slab=169_632 chars, cache_create_tokens=148_891. Gate's
textEq=42K rejected vs imgCost=127K. With live α (1.14 ch/tok),
textEq=149K → ACCEPT. We were leaving real cache_create money on the
table on every one of those calls.
- TransformOptions gains charsPerToken?: number. Default 4 (back-compat).
- isCompressionProfitable() takes charsPerToken as a 5th optional param;
defensive clamp on ≤0 / NaN / Infinity falls back to CHARS_PER_TOKEN.
- All 4 internal gate call sites (static slab + reminder + tool_result
string + tool_result array) thread o.charsPerToken through.
- ProxyConfig.transform now also accepts a function: () => TransformOptions.
Resolved per-request inside createProxy so the host can inject dynamic
values. Static-object form unchanged for Workers / tests.
- node.ts wraps the static transform options in a closure that asks
dashboardState.fitCosts() each request and passes the live
chars_per_token. Fit-null falls through to the baked-in default — no
chicken-and-egg deadlock since normal-sized slabs still feed the fit
ring even before the huge-slab cases get unblocked.
- 4 new gate tests: stale-default rejects the 170K newline-heavy slab;
live α=1.14 flips the same slab to profitable; defensive clamp on
bogus charsPerToken; end-to-end transformRequest passes through.
Tests: 269 → 273 (+4). Typecheck + build clean.
The walker was missing three big text-bearing paths the upstream
tokenizer sees: top-level `tools[]` (name + description + JSON schema),
`tool_use` blocks (name + serialized input), and `thinking` blocks.
Under-counting these inflates α in `tokens ≈ α·textChars + β·pixels`,
which biases the dashboard's `saved_pct` HIGH — the honesty cost
HANDOFF item #1 called out.
- Walker now sums: system + tools[].{name,description,input_schema} +
per-block text/tool_use.input/tool_result.{tool_use_id,content}/
thinking. JSON.stringify via safeStringifyLen() for object fields
so the count matches what the API actually serializes.
- Lift the walker call out of the compression-success path: also run
it on the below_min_chars and not_profitable early returns. Without
this, α was sampled only from "big enough to compress" requests.
- New `outgoingTextChars walker (denominator honesty)` describe block
in render.test.ts: 7 tests covering baseline, tools[], tool_use,
tool_result (string + array forms with image skip), thinking,
unknown-block skipping, and a JSON.stringify(req).length upper bound
asserting walker ≥ 50% of envelope on a content-dense request.
- Confirms walker stays strictly below the JSON envelope (structural
keys/braces still excluded — that's intentional).
Tests: 254 → 261 (+7). Typecheck + build clean.
Paint a 1-pixel-wide mid-gray (191/255) vertical line in the center of
each gutter at multicol >= 2. Same 'visible whitespace' principle as the
U+2192 tab arrow — surfaces structure that pure whitespace alone leaves
ambiguous, at near-zero pixel-token cost (DEFLATE collapses identical
mid-gray runs to ~5 bytes per gutter).
Why now: the user noted gutters relied on whitespace alone, which is
exactly the OCR-reordering risk HANDOFF flagged for multi-col 2 (lines
322-326). An explicit boundary cue lets us push wider multicol or wider
cols in future without spooking the vision encoder into reading
left-to-right across columns.
Tests:
- byte-determinism (existing test still passes)
- inflate IDAT + assert mid-gray pixels at expected divider X
- numCols=1 path stays byte-identical to renderTextToPngs (deterministic
cache_control story for single-col deployments)
Cost: ink=64 pre-invert → 191 post-invert. Doesn't compete with glyph
ink (which lands at 0). At β=0.001776, the divider's ~1568 pixels cost
~3 tokens total per multi-col image. Trivial vs the OCR-clarity win.
The `placement === 'system'` branch attached image blocks to the `system`
field, which Anthropic 400s with `system.N.type: Input should be 'text'`.
The existing CLI help text already warned about this. No tests exercised
the dead branch (grep for `placement.*'system'` finds zero call sites).
`compressSystem` was only consulted inside that same dead branch, so it
went out with it. The other granular `compress{Tools,Schemas,Reminders,
ToolResults}` flags + the `compress` master switch stay — they're useful
debugging toggles with active call sites.
Touched:
- transform.ts: drop both fields from TransformOptions + DEFAULTS;
collapse the if/else around system-rewriting into a bare block (no
re-indentation noise, no behavior change).
- node.ts: drop --placement CLI flag, PLACEMENT env, help text entries,
startup log column, and the TransformOptions wire-up.
- worker.ts: drop PLACEMENT from Env + transform options.
- render.test.ts: refresh three comments that referenced the now-gone
"default placement is 'user'" language; the test bodies were already
correct and didn't reference the removed knobs.
20-line net reduction, 241 tests pass, typecheck + build clean.
Two pieces of work landing together because they're interleaved in
transform.ts and need to ship at the same time for the dashboard
fit-wiring in the next commit to work.
# R2 multi-column rendering (default `multiCol=2`)
Single-col packing wastes ~68% of Anthropic's 1568×1568 image budget
on real Claude Code tool docs (~38 chars/row). The row-aware break-
even gate correctly rejects compression on those slabs — proxy ends
up doing nothing on the heaviest requests. Multi-col packs N text
columns side-by-side per image so each image covers `N×LINES_PER_IMAGE`
wrapped lines, dropping image count by ~N and crossing break-even.
- render.ts: new `renderTextToPngsMultiCol(text, cols, numCols)` with
column-major layout (col 0 fills top-to-bottom, then col 1, …).
Plus `multiColWidth` / `maxFittingCols` helpers. CLI auto-clamps
numCols so the canvas can never exceed the 1568 px width cap.
- transform.ts: `multiCol` option threaded through; gate, image-count
estimator, paging budget, and all render paths take `numCols`.
Intro text now describes column reading order when numCols>1 so
the OCR pass doesn't read row-wise across columns.
- Host wiring: node.ts (--multi-col / MULTI_COL=N, default 2),
worker.ts (MULTI_COL env, default 2). Startup log shows multi_col=N.
- numCols=1 stays a byte-identical passthrough to renderTextToPngs
so flipping back can't regress the cache_control hit rate.
# Empirical-cost instrumentation
The dashboard's `OPUS_IMAGE_TOKEN_COST = 2500` and `CHARS_PER_TOKEN = 4`
are stale pre-Opus-4.7 constants. Fact-checked: 4.7 changed the TEXT
tokenizer only (~1.20× inflation on English, ~1.36× on TypeScript);
image cost is unchanged for same-size images. Direction of error in
the dashboard headline: it UNDERSTATES text savings.
Ditched the "guess from one cold-miss" approach in favor of real
instrumentation that pins both axes at once:
- TransformInfo.imagePixels — Σ width×height across every image
this request (static slab + reminders + tool_results + history
collapse). Threaded through textToImageBlocks, collapseHistory.
- TransformInfo.outgoingTextChars — every char of TEXT remaining
in the transformed outgoing body, computed in one walk before
serialization (countOutgoingTextChars).
- Tracker event schema picks up image_pixels + outgoing_text_chars.
- history.ts: HistoryCollapseInfo.collapsedImagePixels accumulates.
The regression `tokens ≈ α·outgoing_text_chars + β·image_pixels`
over N cold-miss events solves for empirical chars/token (α) and
pixels/token (β) under the live model — no assumed constants.
# Tests
- 8 new render tests covering the multi-col passthrough contract
(numCols=1 byte-identical to renderTextToPngs), canvas dimensions,
image-count halving, determinism, charsRendered sum, estimator
parity, CLI clamp, and CJK wide-glyph wrap.
- paging.test.ts "counts multiple tool_results" threshold loosened
from >770k to >700k to cover both single-col and multi-col budgets
at the same maxImagesPerToolResult cap.
- All 241 tests pass, typecheck + build clean.
renderToolDoc pretty-printed every input_schema with 2-space indent,
putting each property on its own line. At cols=100 this wasted ~70% of
horizontal space — schemas rendered to many short rows instead of a few
dense ones.
Live measurement on 2026-05-19: 150 KB of pretty-printed tool docs in a
177 KB combined slab → 31 static-slab images per request at 40% fill.
With the new row-aware break-even gate (f0176c1), those rejected as
not_profitable — no savings on the user's typical workload.
Synthetic measurement on 30 realistic tool schemas:
- pretty: 320,843 chars / 14,074 lines → 100 images
- compact: 124,720 chars / 179 lines → 10 images
- 2.57× char shrink, 78× row shrink, 10× image cost reduction
Compact JSON is unambiguous: descriptions are already stripped under
compressSchemas, so only structural keys (type/properties/required/
enum/items) remain — those read fluently on one wrapped row. Frontier
models handle compact JSON natively; it's the default wire format for
tool_use blocks anyway.
Test pins the density gain on a representative schema.
isCompressionProfitable previously estimated image count as
ceil(chars / charsPerImage), which assumes uniform full-width line-fill.
renderTextToPngs actually budgets by wrapped visual rows (141 per image),
so newline-heavy code/logs and short-line content render to many more
images than the chars-based estimate predicts.
Live impact: dashboard reported -69% reduction (net loss). 33 compressions
averaged 5494 chars/image (39% fill ratio) — gate under-counted cost by
~9× on sparse content and let net-losing compressions through.
Fix:
- isCompressionProfitable now accepts the full text string; uses
estimateImageCount (the same row-aware math renderTextToPngs uses).
- Adds an optional imageCountCap for paths that truncate before rendering
(tool_results). Cost bounded by cap; savings still measured against
the full pre-truncation length, so 500KB logs still profit.
- All 4 production call sites in transform.ts pass the string. The
tool_result sites also pass maxImagesPerToolResult as the cap.
- Number-arg form retained for back-compat with the existing
isCompressionProfitable(N) unit tests.
Tests:
- 3 new unit tests pin the row-aware regression: sparse content rejected,
dense content accepted, capped content (paging) accepted.
- 7 integration tests previously used 'claude.md\n'.repeat(5000) — sparse
fixtures the new gate correctly rejects. Updated to dense fixtures
('x'.repeat(40000) or single-line repeats without embedded newlines)
so they still exercise the cache_control / determinism / reminder /
tool_result code paths they're meant to.
Steven Chong